Free shipping on all U.S. orders

What is the Hardness of Silicon? How is it Measured?

blog-cards
  • icon2 January 7, 2024
  • icon3 WaferPro
  • icon1 0

On the Mohs scale, which is a relative scale, silicon has a hardness of about 7. Silicon is an extremely useful material in technology and engineering. A key physical property of silicon that impacts performance in many applications is hardness - its ability to resist deformation, scratching, and surface wear. Quantifying silicon's hardness using standardized measurement methods like the Vickers, Rockwell and Mohs scales provides crucial data to material scientists and engineers who depend on silicon parts and components holding up across friction, impacts, and abrasion without failing prematurely. Understanding what influences silicon's hardness at microscopic grain sizes and crystal orientations paves the way for optimizing current uses as well as innovating new silicon composite solutions.

How Silicon Hardness is Measured

There are several scales used to measure hardness, the most common are:

  • Vickers hardness test
  • Rockwell hardness test
  • Brinell hardness test
  • Mohs hardness scale

The differences between the measurements are the method of testing and the units used. But they all quantify the indentation or scratch made in the surface of a material with a harder substance.

Vickers and Knoop tests use a pyramid-shaped diamond indentor tip. The size of the indent left in the material determines its hardness number or value.

Rockwell tests use a diamond cone or hard steel ball to make the indentation. The depth of the indentation correlates to the hardness.

Brinell tests also make use of a hard ball to leave an indent in the metal. The diameter of the indent left behind provides the Brinell hardness number.

The Mohs scale is different since it relies on scratch testing with other known materials ranked 1 - 10 based on established hardness.

Overview of Hardness Tests

TestMethodIndentorUnits
VickersOptical measurement of indent areaDiamond pyramidKg/mm^2
KnoopOptical measurement of indent areaDiamond pyramidKg/mm^2
RockwellDepth measurement of indentDiamond cone or steel ballRockwell units
BrinellOptical measurement of indent diameterHardened steel or tungsten carbide ballKg/mm^2
MohsScratch testing against reference mineralsReference mineralsMohs scale 1 - 10

So while the tests vary, they all aim to quantify the resistance of a material to plastic deformation. Now that we understand the testing methods, we can look specifically at silicon and how it measures on these hardness scales.

The Hardness Value of Silicon

On the Mohs scale, which is a relative scale, silicon has a hardness of about 7. This means it will scratch more common materials like glass, quartz, steel, and titanium. Materials with a Mohs hardness above 7 like diamond, cubic boron nitride, and boron carbide can easily scratch silicon.

For numeric hardness scales, silicon has the following typical hardness values:

  • Vickers hardness: 1000-1300 Kg/mm^2
  • Knoop hardness: 1000-1400 Kg/mm^2
  • Brinell hardness: 3000-4000 MPa
  • Rockwell hardness: 120-150 (Rockwell F scale)

So while silicon is very hard relative to most metals, it is considered a brittle material and not necessarily wear resistant. Materials like diamond, borides, and carbides significantly outperform silicon in abrasion resistance.

What gives silicon its hardness is its atomic structure. With four valence electrons and tetrahedral orientation of its crystal lattice, this covalent bonding allows silicon to resist shearing and deformation forces quite well compared to metallic bonds.

Why Silicon's Hardness Matters

Now that we quantified silicon's hardness properties on the various measurement scales, why does this matter? What are some reasons silicon's degree of hardness is important?

For microelectronics - With transistors and integrated circuits now getting as small as several nanometers, achieving precise etches and features hinges directly on silicon's hardness interfacing with processing methods and compounds.

For MEMS - Microelectromechanical systems with micron sized moving parts have tight tolerance needs where silicon hardness, friction, and wear properties directly affect performance.

For optics - The surface quality and ability to polish silicon determines how effective it is for optical devices and lenses where deep scratches affect light transmission.

For semiconductor manufacturing - All the processing from crystal growth to slicing, polishing, lithography, and doping relies on silicon hardness behaving consistently within expected ranges.

For stronger composites - Mixing silicon carbide and silicon nitride with silicon produces very hard ceramics where balancing hardness, toughness, and chemical resistance is key.

For abrasives - Both silicon carbide and silicon nitride powders are used for grinding, sawing, polishing, and other abrasive processes where their sharp hardness warrants safe handling.

So in summary, knowing the hardness value of silicon is critical for the many applications it serves from electronics to optics, metallurgy to ceramics, and composites to abrasives. Just this one fundamental physical property affects vast technological capabilities we all rely on.

Harder and Softer - Compare and Contrast

How exactly does silicon's hardness measure up compared to other materials? Using the Mohs relative scale and common numeric values, we can differentiate harder and softer relevant materials.

Harder Substances

Diamond - Extremely hard with perfect crystalline structure. 10 Mohs and 10,000 Vickers Knoop hardness number. Abrasively cuts and grinds metals, ceramics, and composites. Used for drilling, sawing, machining, engraving, glass etching.

Cubic boron nitride - Nearly as hard as diamond without the cleavage tendencies. 9-10 Mohs and 4500-6500 Vickers Knoop hardness rating. Hard abrasive for machining steel and other ultra hard materials.

Boron carbide - Made of icosahedra crystal geometry with carbon and boron atoms. 9-9.5 Mohs rating. Nearly as hard as cubic boron nitride. Used for abrasion applications and ballistics armor.

Aluminum oxide - Monocrystalline sapphire with Mohs 9 rating and 2000-4000 Knoop hardness. High strength materials for bulletproof glass, optics, lasers, semiconductors.

Silicon carbide - In the same hardness class as aluminum oxide at 9-9.5 Mohs and 2400-3000 Vickers. Used as an abrasive media and added to alloys and ceramics for hardness.

Tungsten carbide - Extremely hard and dense cobalt cemented carbide. 8-9 Mohs rating. Widely used for machining steel and cast iron parts beyond hardness of tool steel.

Softer Substances

Tool steel - Alloy steel types like A2 and D2 precision ground to extreme precision for knives, tools, gauges, and fixtures. Approximate 4 Mohs, 620 Knoop rating. Holds sharp edges reasonably well.

Titanium alloys - Mohs rating around 5-6. Stronger and lighter than steel for high tech applications but lack hardness for abrasion resistance. Knoop rating as high as 350.

Stainless steel - Ordinary 300 series stainless with a Mohs hardness near 4. Common grades have Brinell rating ranging widely from 125-350 depending on processing and alloy additions.

Aluminum alloys - Light structural metal with Mohs hardness between 2-3. Brinell range from common 6000 grades is only 60-120. Very easily scratched or gouged and needs hard anodizing treatment typically.

Copper alloys - Malleable materials like brass and bronze rate 3-4 for Mohs but usually under 200 on numeric hardness scales. Lead, tin, zinc, and nickle alloys also similar range. Scratched by most metals and have low wear resistance.

Plastics - Materials like nylon, delrin, PVC, acrylic, and polycarbonates fall under 4 Mohs rating and erode very easily. Certain fillers marginally improve scratch resistance.

Interesting Facts about Silicon Hardness

Beyond the technical measurement data, silicon also has some fascinating details around its hardness properties worth noting:

  • Silicon is a semiconductor, not traditionally considered a metal, yet has typical metallic material properties.
  • Single crystal silicon at nano-scale is concluded to be much stronger than large grained silicon.
  • Fracture toughness varies significantly between different silicon crystal growth methods.
  • Most silicon is highly purified polycrystalline for cost reasons yet mono-crystalline is defect-free.
  • Silicon doping changes hardness only at extreme saturation levels that compromise other electrical properties.
  • Ion implantation amended layers increase silicon surface hardness drastically but are very thin.
  • As hardness increases with smaller silicon device geometries, brittleness also increases.
  • Silicon bonds ionically as well as covalently with transition metals to produce very hard silicides.
  • Silicon carbide and silicon nitride bonded composites create extremely hard ceramics.

So while baseline silicon hardness is defined in a range, many factors can push those boundaries substantially. That makes precise control of hardness critical across silicon's many functions.

Examples Requiring Specific Silicon Hardness

What are some specific product examples that rely directly on silicon hardness being within certain limits or require enhancements?

Wafers and Semiconductors

Microchips, transistors, MEMS sensors, and photonic devices built on ultra thin silicon wafers need highly controlled hardness between dies for precision machining. Ion implantation and chemical vapor deposition layers tune hardness in nanometer skins to augment properties only at critical surface interfaces.

Cutting Tools and Nozzles

The wear life of abrasive water jet nozzles and tool bits is extended substantially by using binders with silicon carbide and silicon nitride in the matrix. Operating pressure and cutting speeds are controlled to leverage hardness while minimizing fracturing.

Seal Faces and Bearing Surfaces

Silicon carbide enables mechanical seals and bearings to run hotter, faster, and harder without sacrificing longevity goals. Silicon nitride rolling elements provide high compressive strength and extreme hardness necessary for reliability improvements.

Ballistic Glass and Armor

Laminated polymer sheets can sandwich silicon carbide and boron carbide plates or fibers to drastically improve protective rating standards. These hybrid materials supply exceptional hardness to achieve thickness and weight reductions compared to other solutions.

As you can see, silicon harness enables significant material improvements far beyond just enforcing geometric integrity in semiconductors.

Test Methods for Evaluating Silicon Hardness

With so many applications dependent directly on repeatable silicon hardness, accurate test methods matter greatly. Some key examples include:

Scratch Testing

The simplest technique examines scratches from materials with known harness values. Line patterns can assess deeper damage. Optical measurement of silicon hardness is possible by correlating scratch widths and groove geometry to load forces.

Indentation Mechanics

By accurately pressing a tip into silicon and examining deformation zones and cracking, hardness is inferred from established models. Indenting to precise depths reveals breakdown points useful for engineering limits.

Acoustic Emission Signals

As nanoindentation and fracture mechanics produce dislocations and microcracks, released emission pulses can profile internal stresses and transitions in mechanical behavior. This reveals key material limits.

Tribology Testing

Sliding silicon against virgin silicon while applying normal pressures can isolate attritious wear mechanisms. Subsurface assessment clarifies true removed volume distinguishing plastic flow versus brittle facture modes.

Stress Modeling

Computer simulation of hardness behavior under strain conditions is increasingly accurate. Finite element analysis verifies experimental assumptions while allowing virtual prototyping of new composites before manufacturing.

Having advanced testing capabilities expands the hardness design space for silicon materials science considerably. Modern techniques expose new nanoscale insights.

Optimizing Silicon Hardness

What types of processing adjustments or formulations can extend silicon's hardness most effectively for enhanced performance?

Grain Structures

Growing large single silicon crystals maximizes hardness but is expensive. Small, uniform grains better resist fracturing through dispersing stresses. Nano-crystallization and epitaxial growth push limits further.

Reinforcements

Introducing harder compounds like silicon carbide/nitride particles or whiskers bears the most impact as an intergranular reinforcement. Impeding dislocation propagation is key to optimizing hardness.

Alloying Additions

Certain transition metals covalently bond with silicon increasing shear strength for improved hardness. Elements like boron, germanium, cobalt, nickel, and iron substitute into silicon crystallattice sites effectively.

Surface Treatments

Layering intensely compressed ion implantation case hardening skins onto silicon creates order of magnitude hardness increases in thin sections. Amorphization also contributes beyond just dopant concentrations.

Residual Stresses

Intrinsic processing tensile stresses weaken silicon hardness drastically through microfractures. Developing means for introducing managed compressive stresses improves hardness and wear resistance.

With several routes available to bolster baseline silicon hardness, materials engineers choose different optimization methods matching their fidelity and economic objectives.

Concerns around Increasing Silicon Hardness

It would seem logical that making silicon as hard as possible is always the best approach. But in practice increased hardness comes with caveats and concerns worth discussing upfront:

Brittleness

Very hard materials tend to be less ductile and elastic. Improving hardness makes silicon more prone to fracturing from impacts or concentrated loads. A hardness-toughness balance helps maximize durability.

Thermal Stability

Added dopants, sophisticated processing, and alloying agents risk deteriorating at higher sustained operating temperatures which may be required in service. Thermal stability ensures reliable hardness.

Environmental Factors

Expected chemical or abrasive conditions interact with engineered hardness enhancements unpredictably. Protection coatings help shield vulnerabilities of superficial hardness improvements without rethinking fundamentals.

Design Integration

Great care must be taken when selectively hardening components to avoid stress points in isolation. Graded transitions better distribute forces but complicate processing logistics.

Cost Factors

Economics ultimately drive manufacturing choices so excessive hardening treatments must demonstrate sufficient performance value to warrant process complexities. Sustainable approaches help minimize required hardness levels.

With diligent analysis and testing, silicon hardness can be elevated successfully without undue risk of introducing flaws or deficiencies.

Summary and Conclusions

We've covered extensive ground examining what establishes silicon hardness and why quantifying exact values matters greatly. Both relative scales and measured test numbers convey strength attributes against stresses encountered in service. Maximizing hardness requires astute manipulation of structural order over distances spanning millimeters to nanometers. Yet for all its significance, hardness cannot stand alone as the singular targeted property without also considering adjoining physical behaviors affected. Methodologies for hardness evaluation continue advancing as new composite formulations reveal previously unknown potential. But principles around balancing ultimate limits of hardness, toughness, and manufacturing practicality will not change. Silicon remains the cornerstone binding so many technologies precisely due to the inherent capability of its covalent lattice to resist structural deterioration across vastly differing modalities. That constant trait supports improving products and processes for future generations to come.

Frequently Asked Questions:

What causes a material like silicon to be hard?

Silicon's hardness is due to its atomic structure and the strong covalent bonds formed between silicon atoms. The tetragonal arrangement of bonds in the lattice of silicon crystals allow silicon to resist forces attempting to shear or deform it.

How is the hardness of silicon affected by impurities in the material?

Extreme levels of silicon doping with other elements has minimal impact on hardness. However, impurities introduced as reinforcements like silicon carbide or silicon nitride in small percentages substantially elevates the hardness of the composite.

Does silicon's hardness affect how it can be shaped or machined?

Yes. Silicon's hardness determines what machining processes, tool speeds, coatings, and gage geometries it can withstand. Methods like chemical etching, laser ablation, ultrasonic diamond grinding, and nanoindentation all depend on silicon's hardness characteristics.

What happens to silicon's hardness at cryogenic temperatures?

As silicon is cooled below -150 C both its hardness and brittleness increase. So under super cooled conditions silicon is more prone to catastrophic failure from sudden impacts or tensile loads. Care must be taken in low temperature applications.

Can hardness improvements like ion implantation case hardening be applied only to silicon?

Surface hardening with ion implantation or chemical vapor deposition os common with other materials besides silicon including tool steel, titanium, and cobalt chrome alloys. Such methods greatly improve wear and abrasion resistance.

Build Your Own Wafers

custom-silicon-wafers

Can’t find wafers that meet your desired specs? No problem! We can build wafers with unique specifications to meet your needs.

Request a quotebtn arrow
vector pattern vector pattern vector pattern
image of a slicon waffer
Browse our in-stock wafers ready to ship within 24-48 hours.

Our online store features a wide variety of wafer sizes, orientations, dopants, thicknesses, and more.

Shop onlinebtn arrow